My server sported a nose ring, true, but most of the customers were closer in vintage to the two well-worn horseshoe-shaped counters. Peter Pan still serves egg creams (which I haven't tried) and bakes a decidedly untrendy selection of pastries. This raised donut coated with sugar (80 cents) is about as simple and sweet as it gets.
Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop
727 Manhattan Ave. (Meserole-Norman Aves.), Greenpoint, Brooklyn