The storefront and decor aren't much to see. At The Orchard, all eyes are on the produce, for which you will pay dearly; the lack of overlarge price tags suggests as much. A cherimoya, about the size of a softball and half again as heavy, cost $10, but this was a fair price for a handsome specimen that would also help me to benchmark less shapely cherimoyas in Chinatown.
As it happens, the cherimoya shown here is not the same one I purchased that day. I couldn't pin down the cultivar with certainty, and the crate at The Orchard had offered no clue, but a fruit label with the name Santa Barbara Exotics offered a lead. The California farm grows three varieties, according to owner Peter Nichols: Lisa, Bay, and White. Based on my after-the-fact description — I'd already scooped clean the super-creamy flesh, evocative of pear and pineapple, at a single sitting — Mr. Nichols opined that the Lisa cultivar was most likely.
After follow-up research, I'm confident he was correct. Shortly thereafter Mr. Nichols kindly shipped me several end-of-season cherimoyas of all three varieties, clearly labeled, as well as a half-dozen tennis-ball-size white sapotes to help fill in the gaps between the larger fruits. This fully ripened Lisa cherimoya, whose skin, not atypically, had turned slightly brown but whose flesh remained resolutely white, was one share of that booty.
The Orchard
1367 Coney Island Ave. (Ave. J-Cary Ct.), Midwood, Brooklyn
718-377-1799
www.OrchardFruit.com